Why I Nodded Along Instead of Asking
I’m talking with a friend, and he mentions a name. It’s obvious I’m supposed to know, but I don’t. In that half a second, I make a quiet choice: I don’t stop him and ask who that is. I just nod along, and I didn’t fully follow what he was trying to communicate.
Afterward, I felt stupid for not asking, even though it wouldn’t have made any difference to him for me to ask. It was really just my pride getting in the way, and wanting to look competent and like I had the knowledge that was obviously expected of me.
“I don’t know” would have fixed it instantly. Why is it sometimes so hard to say?
The Same Three Words, No Problem
Recently I was at the gym doing my two-mile walk while listening to a Mac Power Users episode on launchers. David Sparks described all the functions he uses Alfred for on his Mac. I’ve had that app on my Mac for years and used it for just a few things, such as launching apps and doing searches.
My reaction to listening to David describe what he uses Alfred for, and the realization of how much I didn’t know, wasn’t embarrassment at all. Instead, I realized I was grossly underutilizing this app and wanted to learn more.
Admitting I didn’t know Alfred was effortless. The same three words, but none of the sting from the conversation with my friend. The only thing that changed was that nobody was watching and nobody expected me to already know.
The moment that I owned my lack of knowledge, my curiosity opened up. It sent me back through David’s Alfred Field Guide, which I’m working through now.
I’m now using functions that I had either completely forgotten about or never learned. For instance, I needed to look up a location in Apple Maps.
Instead of grabbing the mouse, finding the icon, opening the app, hunting for the search box, and typing in the words, I can open Alfred with two keystrokes, type “maps,” and search the location right in Apple Maps, which automatically opens the app to the search location.
Admitting my lack of knowledge of Alfred’s many helpful features was the unlock that led me to seek more information and learn new things. Anne-Laure Le Cunff wrote about this dynamic in her Ness Labs Newsletter article, Reclaiming Your Ignorance:
“Ignorance doesn’t have to be the enemy of knowledge. When you face it directly, it can become fuel for curiosity. This requires knowing exactly what you know, what you don’t, and being honest about the difference.”
The Real Trigger Isn’t Ignorance — It’s an Audience
When I’m volunteering as a ranger at the Minuteman Missile National Historic Site, and a visitor asks me something I don’t know, I say so without any hesitation. In that setting, it’s not an issue.
It’s not just not knowing that makes me hesitate to say “I don’t know.” The friction shows up when I value a personal relationship, or when I’m in front of an audience expecting me to know it, and I don’t.
The hesitation that I have to say, “I don’t know,” only seems to appear when I feel the need to try to protect other people’s opinion of me. If there’s no audience, or there’s no personal relationship, or there’s no expectation of knowledge, it’s not an issue.
In reality, in almost all situations where this arises, it wouldn’t have been the negative that I imagine. Often I’ve found that it actually gives others a more positive impression of me when I admit I don’t know something.
Adam Grant described this process in his book, Think Again: The Power of Knowing What You Don’t Know:
“Admitting we were wrong doesn’t make us look less competent. It’s a display of honesty and a willingness to learn.”
Saying “I don’t know” can actually raise people’s opinion of you, not lower it. People see it as an admirable character trait.
Give Yourself Permission to Not Be the Expert
There will always be situations where we worry about the opinions of people that we care about or audiences that expect us to be competent.
The key to learning to be open about our lack of knowledge is to intentionally choose to embrace a beginner’s mind.
The ancient Greek philosopher Epictetus described the benefits of having a beginner’s mind in Epictetus and Sharon Lebell, The Art of Living:
“Behold the world fresh—as it is, on its own terms—through the eyes of a beginner. To know that you do not know and to be willing to admit that you do not know without sheepishly apologizing is real strength and sets the stage for learning and progress in any endeavor.”
To do so, we must discard the expectation we have of ourselves (which isn’t realistic and we know isn’t true) of being the all-knowing expert. It’s okay, and actually an advantage, to allow ourselves to be fully human, gaps of knowledge and all.
3 Things You Gain Every Time You Say “I Don’t Know”
Here’s what you gain when you admit “I don’t know:”
- You actually understand what’s being said instead of nodding along in the dark.
- You come across as more honest and authentic — because you’re willing to admit when you don’t know.
- You open the door to real learning.
My recent experience with Alfred is an example. I admitted “I don’t know,” worked with curiosity to increase my knowledge, and a tool I’d owned for years became more useful.
It opens the door to curiosity and learning. As Anne-Laure Le Cunff wrote in Reclaiming Your Ignorance,
“When we can’t admit what we don’t know, we stop learning and growing.”
Imagine admitting “I don’t know” in the moments that scare you, the ones with an audience. Think of the real advantages you gain by simply being willing to say “I don’t know.”
Saying you don’t know something isn’t negative, and it’s not an admission of failure. Rather, it’s an opportunity to be authentic, be honest, and learn something new.
Trade Looking Smart for Getting Smarter
Here’s the quiet part of the power: nobody hands you a prize for saying “I don’t know.” No applause, no gold star.
What you get is quieter than that — you actually understand the thing, people trust you a little more, and a door you didn’t know was closed swings open. That’s the whole trade.
You give up looking smart for a second, and you get to be smarter for good. It’s worth it almost every time.
The next time a friend drops a name I don’t recognize, I want to just ask. “Who’s that?” It costs me nothing but a moment of looking less informed, and it buys me the whole rest of the conversation.
The next time it happens to you, notice the little flinch of pride, and say the three words anyway. See what opens up.
Note: I wrote this blog post myself using my own words and thoughts for the initial draft. I used AI only to suggest headlines, section headings, images and text improvements.
Links to product pages on Amazon include a referral code which pays me a small percentage of the sale when products are purchased. This helps to defray some of the costs of running this site. I strive to only include links to products I believe are worth purchasing.